Judge strikes wording from Trump documents case but will not dismiss charges

11 June 2024, 08:24

Former US president Donald Trump
Former US president Donald Trump. Picture: PA

A paragraph has been struck from the indictment.

The federal judge presiding over the classified documents case against former president Donald Trump and two of his associates struck a paragraph from the indictment on Monday.

Still, they denied a defence request to dismiss some of the charges.

The paragraph concerns allegations that Trump, in 2021, while no longer president, showed a classified map of a foreign country to a representative of his political action committee while discussing a military operation that he said was not going well.

Defence lawyers said the paragraph was prejudicial because it included information that was not irrelevant to the indictment, which accuses Trump of illegally retaining classified documents at his Mar-a-Lago estate, and US District Judge Aileen Cannon on Monday agreed that the language’s inclusion in charging documents was “not appropriate”.

She left the rest of the indictment intact, denying in her 14-page order a defence request to dismiss actual charges in the indictment.

Trump Classified Documents
The indictment against former president Donald Trump (Jon Elswick/AP)

But even as she did that, she chided special counsel Jack Smith’s team for including language in the indictment that she said was “legally unnecessary to serve the function of an indictment” and for creating “arguable confusion” in the allegations.

The motion to dismiss the counts is one of multiple pretrial requests and disputes that have piled up before Ms Cannon for months.

These have snarled the case’s progress and prompted the judge last month to indefinitely postpone a trial that had been set for May 20 in Fort Pierce, Florida.

She has scheduled additional arguments for later this month, including on a Trump challenge to the legality and funding of the Justice Department’s appointment of Mr Smith as special counsel last year.

The delays are all the more startling given that many legal experts had seen the classified documents case as exceedingly straightforward.

The case alleged that Trump had illegally hoarded classified documents from his presidency at his Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach, Florida, and obstructed FBI efforts to get them back.

The prosecution is one of four criminal cases Trump faces as he seeks to reclaim the White House.

The defendants in this particular motion had sought to throw out more than a half-dozen counts in the indictment, which also accuses Trump of conspiring with valet Walt Nauta and Mar-a-Lago property manager Carlos De Oliveira to conceal the sensitive files from the government.

The defendants had challenged counts related to obstruction and false statements.

Still, Ms Cannon said in an order on Monday that “the identified deficiencies, even if generating some arguable confusion, are either permitted by law, raise evidentiary challenges not appropriate for disposition at this juncture, and/or do not require dismissal even if technically deficient, so long as the jury is instructed appropriately and presented with adequate verdict forms as to each Defendants’ alleged conduct”.

Ms Cannon has already rejected multiple other motions to dismiss the case, including one that suggested that Trump was authorised under a statute known as the Presidential Records Act to keep the documents with him after he left the White House and to designate them as his personal files.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Vehicles pass the Tesla gigafactory in Austin, Texas

Tesla shareholders vote to restore Elon Musk’s pay package

President Joe Biden and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, left, shake hands after signing a security agreement on the sidelines of the G7 in Savelletri, Italy

US President Joe Biden and Ukraine’s Volodymyr Zelensky sign security deal

G7 leaders at the summit in southern Italy

G7 summit opens with deal to use frozen Russian assets for Ukraine

Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks to reporters at the National Republican Senatorial Committee in Washington

Donald Trump returns to Capitol Hill and whips up Republican legislators

US President Joe Biden participates in a working session with world leaders during a G7 summit at Borgo Egnazia, Italy

Biden says no Gaza ceasefire deal soon, as mediators work to bridge gaps

Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich waves and smiles as he stands in a glass cage in a courtroom at the First Appeals Court of General Jurisdiction in Moscow, Russia, on April 23 2024

US reporter Evan Gershkovich, held in Russia on espionage charges, to face trial

This image provided by Tamatha Bibbo, principal of the Pollard Middle School in Needham, Massachusetts, shows 23 sets of twins who graduated from Pollard Middle School

Double take: 23 sets of twins graduate from single Massachusetts middle school

Elephant Bubi kicks the ball towards the goal in Starkenberg, Germany

Bubi the elephant predicts Germany to win Euro 2024 opener against Scotland

Russia’s Kazan nuclear-powered submarine arrives at the port of Havana, Cuba, on Wednesday

US submarine pulls into Guantanamo Bay day after Russian warships arrive in Cuba

The 'Happy Days' actor shared a grinning selfie with Dublin Fire Brigade

Happy Days for The Fonz: Henry Winkler thanks firefighters after blaze at Dublin hotel

Rishi Sunak with Italian PM Giorgia Meloni

Rishi Sunak receives warm welcome at G7 summit as he reunites with Italian PM

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky walks past various international flags on arrival at the G7 in Borgo Egnazia, Italy

How will move to lend Ukraine billions backed by Russia’s frozen assets work?

A tourist fans a companion in front of the the Parthenon at the Acropolis in Athens

Heatwave forces Greek authorities to shut Acropolis in afternoon for second day

Bulgarian former prime minister Boyko Borissov, leader of the centre-right GERB party

Bulgarian ex-premier Borissov offers coalition but does not want job again

A Polish soldier patrols the border with Belarus

Poland reintroduces restrictions along Belarus border due to migration pressures

Eric Calibet smiling in a black t-shirt with his arms spread out.

Retired US cop missing on Greek island days after Michael Mosley's body found - as temperatures hit 40 degrees