Jury selection enters pivotal stretch as Trump’s hush money trial resumes

18 April 2024, 17:14

APTOPIX Trump Hush Money
APTOPIX Trump Hush Money. Picture: PA

Lawyers still need to pick 11 more jurors to serve on the panel that will decide the first-ever criminal case against a former US president.

Jury selection in Donald Trump ’s hush money case encountered new setbacks Thursday as a previously seated juror was excused after backtracking on whether she felt she could be impartial and fair. The status of a second sworn-in juror was also in limbo over concerns that some of his previous answers to questions were not accurate.

Lawyers still need to pick 12 more jurors to serve on the panel that will decide the first-ever criminal case against a former US president.

Trump Hush Money
Former President Donald Trump, flanked by attorneys Todd Blanche and Emil Bove (Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post/AP)

Seven jurors were seated on Tuesday after being grilled for hours by lawyers on everything from their hobbies to social media posts to their opinion of the presumptive Republican nominee in this year’s closely contested presidential race.

Prosecutors on Thursday also asked Judge Juan M Merchan to sanction Mr Trump over seven more social media posts they say violate a gag order that bans Mr Trump from attacking witnesses.

The prosecution on Monday sought a 3,000 dollar (£2,600) fine against Mr Trump over three Truth Social posts.

Trump Hush Money
Former President Donald Trump addresses the media following the second day of jury selection at Manhattan criminal court (Michael Santiago/AP)

More than half the members of a group of 96 prospective jurors brought into the courtroom were dismissed on Thursday, most after saying they doubted their ability to be fair and impartial.

Earlier, one of the seven jurors who had been picked, an oncology nurse, said upon further consideration that she was no longer confident she could be impartial.

Although the jurors’ names are being kept confidential, the woman said her family members and friends questioned her about being a juror.

She was then excused, leaving six on the panel so far, including a software engineer, an information technology professional, a sales professional, an English teacher and two lawyers.

After dismissing the juror, Judge Juan Merchan ordered journalists in court not to report prospective jurors’ answers to questions about their current and former employers.

Trump Hush Money
Lawyers are seeking to find 12 more jurors to serve on the panel (Michael M. Santiago/AP)

A second juror was also in limbo on Thursday over concerns that some of his answers in court may not have been accurate.Prosecutors found an article from the 1990s about a man with the same name as the juror being arrested for tearing down political advertisements. The posters were on the political right, Assistant District Attorney Joshua Steinglass said.

Mr Steinglass also disclosed that a relative of the man may have been involved in a non-prosecution agreement in the 1990s with the Manhattan district attorney’s office, which is prosecuting Mr Trump’s case.

Judge Merchan had instructed the man to come to court on Thursday morning to answer questions and verify whether the people involved were him or his relative.

Mr Merchan noted the juror’s apparent “reluctance to come in” and asked both sides if they’d consent to having him removed without further inquiry.

Mr Trump’s lawyer Todd Blanche declined, saying he wanted to first hear what the man had to say.

Under questioning earlier this week, the man had said he hadn’t been convicted of a crime.

Trump Hush Money
Former President Donald Trump awaits the start of proceedings on the second day of jury selection at Manhattan criminal court (Michael Santiago/AP)

Twelve more people must still be sworn in, with the judge saying he anticipated opening statements in the landmark case to be given as early as next week.

After dismissing the juror, Judge Juan Merchan ordered journalists in court not to report prospective jurors’ answers to questions about their current and former employers.

He said that “as evidenced by what’s happened already, it’s become a problem.” The answers also will be redacted from court transcripts.

Dozens of prospective jurors were dismissed both days after saying they could not be impartial or had other commitments that would conflict with the trial, which is expected to last several weeks.

Mr Trump has pleaded not guilty to 34 counts of falsifying business records as part of an alleged scheme to bury stories he feared could damage his 2016 campaign.

Trump Hush Money
Six jurors have been selected in Donald Trump’s criminal case (Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post/AP)

The allegations focus on payoffs to two women, pornography actor Stormy Daniels and Playboy model Karen McDougal, who said they had extramarital sexual encounters with Mr Trump years earlier, as well as to a Trump Tower doorman who claimed to have a story about a child he alleged Mr Trump had out of wedlock.

Mr Trump says none of these supposed sexual encounters occurred.

The case is the first of Mr Trump’s four indictments to reach trial.

The seating of the Manhattan jury will be a seminal moment in the case, setting the stage for a trial that will place the former president’s legal jeopardy at the heart of the campaign against Democrat Joe Biden and feature potentially unflattering testimony about Mr Trump’s private life in the years before he became president.

The process of picking a jury is a critical phase of any criminal trial but especially so when the defendant is a former president and the presumptive Republican nominee.

Trump Hush Money
One juror was excused after admitting she could not be impartial in the case (Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post/AP)

Prosecutors have also asked for the former president to be held in contempt and fined because of seven social media posts that they say violated a judge’s gag order barring him from attacking witnesses.

The social media posts at issue were made by Mr Trump after Monday when prosecutors first sought a 3,000 dollar (£2,400) fine for Mr Trump for three Truth Social posts they said violated the order.

Prosecutor Christopher Conroy said several of the posts involved an article that referred to Mr Trump’s former lawyer Michael Cohen as a “serial perjurer”, and one from Wednesday that repeated a claim by a Fox News host that liberal activists were lying to get on the jury.

Mr Trump’s lawyer Emil Bove said Mr Cohen “has been attacking President Trump in public statements,” and Mr Trump was just replying.

The judge had already scheduled a hearing for next week on the prosecution’s request for contempt sanctions over Mr Trump’s posts.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Hunter Biden

Hunter Biden’s impending gun trial mired in disagreements over evidence

Uvalde Shooting-Anniversary

Families of Uvalde victims sue Meta, video game maker and gun firm

Sean Kingston House Raid

Sean Kingston and mother alleged to have committed million dollars of fraud

OBIT Caleb Carr

Caleb Carr, military historian and author of The Alienist, dies at 68

US Kenya

US defence secretary Lloyd Austin to undergo medical procedure

France Syria Torture Trial

Paris court sentences three Syrian officials in absentia for war crimes

WHO Pandemic Treaty

Efforts to draft pandemic treaty falter as countries disagree on future response

Palestinian flag outside ICJ

Top UN court orders Israel to halt military operation in Rafah

Israel Palestinians

Egypt says it will send aid trucks into Gaza through Kerem Shalom crossing

Belarus Russia

Putin questions Zelensky’s legitimacy as Ukraine’s leader

Australia US Pilot

Sydney judge allows extradition of US ex-fighter pilot accused of training Chinese

Vatican Pope Millennial Saint

Italian teenage computer ace set to become first millennial generation saint

Director Morgan Spurlock attends a special screening of ‘RATS’ on August 26, 2013 in New York City.

Super Size Me filmmaker Morgan Spurlock dies at 53


China deploys dozens of warplanes and ships near Taiwan

Syria IS

British woman and three children linked to IS in Syria handed to UK delegation

Morgan Spurlock has died aged 53.

Super Size Me documentary maker Morgan Spurlock dies aged 53