Robert Mugabe: Remembering Zimbabwe's divisive 'dictator'

6 September 2019, 13:25

Robert Mugabe was one of Africa's most controversial leaders in recent history
Robert Mugabe was one of Africa's most controversial leaders in recent history. Picture: PA
Nick Hardinges

By Nick Hardinges

An enigma. A paradox. A liberation hero? Or a ruthless dictator? Robert Mugabe's legacy will forever divide opinion.

Fewer world leaders have caused as much controversy on the international stage than the former prime minister and president of Zimbabwe has over the last half-century.

His adoring supporters will tell you he was a hero who led his country's bid for independence and Rhodesia's white-minority rule.

Ultimately, he was one of the key architects of removing British colonialism and establishing Zimbabwe as free nation.

But he has also been criticised for overseeing a disastrous land reform programme, causing hyperinflation and rigging elections.

More seriously, Mugabe has been consistently accused of human rights abuses.

But whether you condemned or commended the leader, regularly described as a dictator, his impact will never be forgotten.

His death marks the end of an era for the former British colony.

Robert Mugabe died aged 95
Robert Mugabe died aged 95. Picture: PA

Who was Robert Mugabe?

Mr Mugabe was indeed a hero of the African continent's struggles against colonialism and white supremacism and Zimbabwe stands today as an independent, sovereign nation because of the efforts of the late leader.

He was imprisoned for a decade without trial for opposing British rule in Southern Rhodesia, now Zimbabwe, and helped overthrow Ian Smith, Rhodesia's white prime minister.

In 1980, he won his country's first general election with an overwhelming victory for the Zimbabwe African National Union(ZANU) and renamed Rhodesia to what we now know as Zimbabwe.

In doing so he gave hope to black Zimbabweans and black Africans, introducing healthcare and educational reforms along the way and turning his country into one of the most promising and upcoming on the continent.

In his early political years Mugabe was seen as a hero of Zimbabwe
In his early political years Mugabe was seen as a hero of Zimbabwe. Picture: PA

As a result, positive tributes have poured in that celebrate his legacy with Zimbabwe's current president Emmerson Mnangagwa leading the way.

He said on Twitter: "It is with the utmost sadness that I announce the passing on of Zimbabwe's founding father and former President, Cde Robert Mugabe.

"Cde Mugabe was an icon of liberation, a pan-Africanist who dedicated his life to the emancipation and empowerment of his people. His contribution to the history of our nation and continent will never be forgotten.

"May his soul rest in eternal peace."

But Mr Mugabe's success in delivering independence and fighting for pan-Africanism are overshadowed by his reign as the country's leader.

Protests over Mugabe's regime came from all over the world
Protests over Mugabe's regime came from all over the world. Picture: PA

Between becoming prime minister in 1980 and establishing himself as president in 1987, he used government forces to crush political opponents and killed 20,000 civilians, an accusation that he always denied.

In 2000, he encouraged black Zimbabweans to violently seize white-owned farms under the land reform programme under the guise of decolonisation, leading to a breakdown in food production, economic decline and international sanctions.

After surviving another election in 2002, one which drew widespread criticism from the international community over its validity, his country was suspended from the British Commonwealth over accusations of human rights abuses.

By 2008, hyperinflation had rocketed making the currency worthless and forcing millions of people to leave the country.

Many in the international community condemned Mugabe's behaviour
Many in the international community condemned Mugabe's behaviour. Picture: PA

Several contentious elections and a fight against cancer later, Mr Mugabe was ousted from power during an army coup d'état that saw vice-President Emmerson Mnangagwa replace him.

It is for these reasons why some people have spoken out against the memory of the former leader.

The late John Makumbe, a politics professor at the University of Zimbabwe, said: “He’ll be remembered as a villain. His legacy was destroyed by his staying, his violence, his imposing his own political allies and rivals.

“Robert Mugabe always had the seed of bad governance, cruelty, selfishness: ‘It’s only me who matters.’ He came in 1980 and donors flooded in; Mugabe looked angelic, he took on the colour of his surroundings. But by 2000 he had to rig elections and the rot had set in.

“The chameleon has its own colour: when it’s frightened, it takes on its original colour, and it’s ugly. He showed his true colours. His true colour is a killer. He killed his enemies.”

Mugabe met with many world leaders throughout his life
Mugabe met with many world leaders throughout his life. Picture: PA

Along the way he shared stages with world leaders, meeting the Queen, Bill Clinton and the Pope. Each occasion was, unsurprisingly, a controversy.

And it is that controversy that will forever follow his legacy.

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Evacuations were ordered for remote communities near a new fast-moving wildfire in mountains north of Los Angeles.

New wildfire explodes north of Los Angeles, forcing evacuations across communities

Donald Trump holds a letter that former President Joe Biden left for him

Donald Trump reveals what Joe Biden wrote in 'inspirational' farewell letter

Primary school children reading in a classroom in the UK.

Gender pay gap starts at 6, study finds, as boys ‘tend to overestimate their abilities compared to girls’

In this photo provided by Ukraine's 65th Mechanised Brigade press service, a Ukrainian soldier pets his cat standing by the Christmas tree on the frontline in Zaporizhzhia region, Ukraine, Tuesday, Dec. 31, 2024.

Ukrainian troops using cat meows to ‘lure Russian troops towards booby-traps’

Aschaffenburg, Germany. 22nd Jan, 2025. Fire and rescue service vehicles are parked near the scene of a crime.

Horror as two-year-old boy and man killed in knife rampage in German park, as Afghan suspect arrested

Margo Neas holds her cat Mittens at her home in Melbourne, Australia

Mittens the cat becomes accidental jetsetter after being forgotten on a plane by mistake

The British boy, originally from Oldham, was 11 years old when he went missing while travelling with his family in Marbella, Spain, in October 2017.

Alex Batty’s mum & granddad won't face criminal charges after keeping Brit teen in commune for six years

Humanitarian aid trucks enter through the Kerem Shalom crossing from Egypt into the Gaza Strip, as a ceasefire deal between Israel and Hamas went into effect, in Rafah, Tuesday, Jan. 21, 2025. (AP Photo/Jehad Alshrafi)

Israel confirms control of Rafah border crossing into Gaza during first phase of ceasefire deal

Donald Trump and First Lady Melania Trump in the crowd for the church service

Trump demands apology from Washington bishop who warned he was sowing fear among LGBTQ people

Donald Trump speak in the Roosevelt Room at the White House on January 21, 2025

Pregnant women and rights groups sue Trump over ‘flagrantly illegal’ birthright citizenship executive order

At least 66 people died in the fire

Four arrested after at least 76 people killed in devastating fire at ski resort in Turkey

Henry 'Enrique' Tarrio

Oath Keepers founder and former Proud Boys leader released from prison

Palestinians walk through the destruction caused by the Israeli air and groun

Palestinians confront landscape of destruction in Gaza’s ‘ghost towns’

President Donald Trump, and first lady Melania Trump

Donald Trump’s first full day includes firings and an infrastructure announcement

Firefighters work to extinguish a fire in a hotel at a ski resort of Kartalkaya in Bolu

Turkey ski resort hotel fire kills at least 66 people and dozens more injured

A female protester holds a flag

Iraq passes Bill that critics say legalises child marriage