Maui judge bars insurers from going after fire victims after settlement reached

14 August 2024, 03:04

Hawaii Wildfire Settlement
Hawaii Wildfire Settlement. Picture: PA

A multi-billion-dollar wildfire settlement is one step closer to being finalised.

A Maui judge’s ruling on Tuesday resolves a critical roadblock to finalising a 4 billion dollar (£3.1 billion) wildfire settlement.

Insurance companies who have paid out more than 2 billion dollars (£1.5 billion) in claims can seek reimbursement only from the settlement amount defendants fire victims blame for causing the deadly tragedy have agreed to pay.

Lawyers representing the victims in hundreds of lawsuits over the deaths and destruction caused by the fires asked the judge to bar insurers from bringing independent legal action to recoup the money paid to policyholders.

Preventing insurers from going after the defendants is a key settlement term.

Hawaii Wildfire Anniversary
Waiola Church and nearby Lahaina Hongwanji Mission are engulfed in flames. (Matthew Thayer/AP)

The settlement was reached earlier this month, days before the first anniversary of the fires, amid fears that Hawaiian Electric, the power company that some blame for sparking the blaze, could be on the brink of bankruptcy.

Other defendants include Maui County and large landowners.

The federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives is investigating the August 2023, fires that killed 102 people, destroyed the historic downtown area of Lahaina, burned thousands of homes and displaced 12,000 people.

Lawyers were worried allowing insurers to pursue reimbursement separately would be a deal-breaker, drain what is available to pay fire victims, and lead to prolonged litigation.

A group of more than 160 property and casualty insurers that have paid more than 2.34 billion dollars (£1.8 billion) to people and businesses devastated by the fires remained as holdouts to the settlement.

Insurer lawyers argued in court filings that what they called the rush to push through a settlement deprives the insurers of their due process.

The insurance industry has been unfairly demonised while those responsible for the fires won’t be held accountable, insurer lawyer Vincent Raboteau told the judge.

Hawaii Wildfire Anniversary Banyan Tree
A man reacts as he sits on the Lahaina historic banyan tree damaged by the wildfire. (Rick Bowmer/PA)

“And we’re not arguing to be first in line for anything,” he said.

“It’s always been our position that individual plaintiffs should get the lion’s share.”

After the hearing, Mr Raboteau declined to comment on Judge Peter Cahill’s ruling and would not say whether they plan to ask the Hawaii Supreme Court to review it.

Jake Lowenthal, a lawyer selected as one of four liaisons for the coordination of the plaintiffs’ lawsuits, said they are heartened by Judge Cahill’s ruling.

“This is going to be a critical part in reaching a final resolution of everyone’s claims as well as resolving the insurance companies’ potential rights of reimbursement,” he said.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Vladimir Putin must stop playing games with a ceasefire and come to the table, Sir Keir Starmer said, as he convenes world leaders to discuss peacekeeping in Ukraine

Starmer to host Ukraine peace summit - as he warns Putin to 'stop playing games' with ceasefire and come to table

Donald Trump speaks at the Justice Department

Trump insists peace talks with Russia are going 'really well' despite Putin being accused of 'delaying tactics'

The MV Stena Immaculate tanker after it was hit by the MV Solong container vessel in the North Sea

Captain of container ship Solong which crashed into US oil tanker charged with gross negligence manslaughter

Mark Carney

'It's crazy': Mark Carney says Canada will 'never be 51st US state', as he is sworn in as PM after Trump threats

Vladimir Putin has been accused of "delaying" tactics

Putin accused of 'delaying tactics' over Ukraine truce deal, as Zelenskyy says Russia is 'sabotaging diplomacy'

Mark Carney is sworn in as prime minister during a ceremony at Rideau Hall in Ottawa on Friday

Former Bank of England governor Mark Carney sworn in as Prime Minister of Canada

Trump said he will end the 'mess' of the Ukraine war

Trump hails 'good and productive' talks with Russia as he urges Putin to spare lives of Ukrainian troops

Hamas accepts deal to release American-Israeli hostage Edan Alexander and bodies of four dual-nationals

Hamas accepts deal to release American-Israeli hostage Edan Alexander and bodies of four dual-nationals

Close up of a dachshund sausage dog in long grass

Sausage dog mauls newborn baby to death after vets refused to euthanise it

Kenyan President William Ruto's motorcade

British pensioner killed in hit-and-run by Kenyan president’s motorcade

Exclusive
Speaking to LBC’s Nick Ferrari, Sir Peter Wall warned Vladimir Putin will “not come to the party” on the terms currently being put forward for a ceasefire in Ukraine.

Ukraine ceasefire is ‘not at all close’ and could take 'years,’ former chief of British army tells LBC

The US 'hunting' influencer fled Australia following backlash over video of her snatching baby wombat from its mother

US influencer flees Australia following backlash over video of her snatching baby wombat from its mother

Russian President Vladimir Putin speaks during a joint news conference with Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko following their talks at the Grand Kremlin Palace in Moscow, Russia, Thursday, March 13, 2025. (AP Photo/Alexander Zemlianichenko)

Peace deal on Putin's terms: Russian leader sets out conditions as Zelenskyy says Russia 'wants to drag war out'

American Airlines jet bursts into flames at Denver Airport as terrified passengers forced to escape onto wing

American Airlines jet bursts into flames at Denver Airport as terrified passengers forced to escape onto wing

Donald Trump speaks during a meeting with NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte at the White House

'US will annex Greenland', says Trump as he warns Nato 'might have to get involved' in takeover

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy

'Very manipulative': Zelenskyy slams Putin's peace deal comments as he says Russia 'wants to drag war out'