Government's face mask rules are "not scientific whatsoever," says public health expert

13 July 2020, 15:28 | Updated: 13 July 2020, 15:35

By Fiona Jones

This public health doctor explained to LBC why the Government's rules around face masks are strategic and "not scientific whatsoever."

Wearing face coverings in shops and other public enclosed spaces in England may become mandatory, the Prime Minister suggested on Friday.

Mr Johnson, who was seen wearing a face mask for the first time, said "stricter rules were being looked at" to prevent a second peak of coronavirus.

Evidence-based healthcare expert Dr Simon Kolstoe told Shelagh Fogarty the Government's rules around face masks "are not scientific whatsoever" and are instead strategic.

"We know face masks are routinely used when we need infection control...and the fact is if you went to hospital and you saw your surgeon wearing a face mask that he'd made that morning out of a tea towel in his kitchen you'd be very rightly concerned," he said.

This is proof that the face masks used in medical settings are certified and made to specific standards - unlike using a scarf as a face covering, Dr Simon said.

Government&squot;s face mask rules are "not scientific whatsoever," says public health expert
Government's face mask rules are "not scientific whatsoever," says public health expert. Picture: PA

"The big problem that we have here is we know these certified masks are effective but if the Government goes out and tells everyone you ought to be wearing these things, there'd be panic buying of these masks and there wouldn't be any available for the NHS.

"Thus the advice we've seen has pulled back a bit and says wear a face covering if possible. That's what's led us to this entire situation," he said.

Dr Simon explained there are a number of different standards of mask used in hospitals depending on the environment but they all undergo rigorous testing; he told Shelagh local hospital, Southampton General, shared this view and have been checking peoples' quality of masks on entry.

On balance, he said, it is "absolutely" a good thing for face masks to be worn in confined indoor spaces, "but you can't expect everyone wearing faces masks to be making them to the same standard as certified devices" and testing each face mask is of course a practical impossibility.

Dr Simon did say that research has shown that the tightness of the mask around the face is a strong factor in how effective each mask is.

"You might be lucky, you might make something at home that turns out to be extremely effective but without testing these things there's no way of really knowing," he reiterated.

He cited Wales' rule of wearing a two or three ply face mask as a "step in the right direction" and told LBC that ideally in the near future there would be visible stamp of quality on effective masks.

Dr Simon said that while covering your mouth is probably "better than nothing" there is a vast variability on this.

More Shelagh Fogarty News

See more More Shelagh Fogarty News

Headteacher tells LBC of more than £67,000 increase in her school's energy bills

Headteacher tells LBC of more than £67,000 increase in her school's energy bills

Governance 'undermined' by No10 'survival' culture, Shad. Chief Treasury Sec tells Shelagh Fogarty

Governance 'undermined' by No10 'survival' culture, Shad Chief Treasury Sec tells Shelagh Fogarty

Shelagh Fogarty's devastating takedown of Boris Johnson partygate denial

Shelagh Fogarty's devastating takedown of Boris Johnson partygate denial

'Morally inept' NDA practice in uni sex cases must be scrapped, Minister insists

'Morally inept' uni sex case NDAs must be scrapped, Minister demands

Partygate scandal: 'I will never vote Conservative again,' caller says

Partygate scandal: 'I will never vote Conservative again,' passionate caller says

Ex-Met standards boss defends lack of No10 party investigations

Ex-Met standards boss defends lack of No10 party investigation

Tory MP Sir Roger Gale tells LBC party has to replace Boris Johnson as leader

Tory MP Sir Roger Gale tells LBC Boris Johnson has to be replaced as leader

Shelagh Fogarty's passionate clash with caller defending No10 party

Shelagh Fogarty's passionate clash with caller defending Number 10 party

Pavan Sagoo passed away in the same month Downing Street held a party for staff.

Mum who lost daughter, 14, during May 2020 lockdown too devastated to say the PM's name

Cladding crisis: Caller facing bankruptcy and 'fighting it every single day on credit cards'

Cladding crisis: Caller fighting bankruptcy 'every single day on credit cards'

Colston's Girls' School ex-pupil reveals 'inappropriate' rituals to slave trader

Colston's Girls' School ex-pupil reveals 'inappropriate' rituals to slave trader

'I will now say that I forgive the person who killed my son'

'I will now say that I forgive the person who killed my son'

Shelagh Fogarty takes issue with caller saying PM lies with 'every word'

Best of 2021: Shelagh Fogarty takes issue with caller saying PM lies with 'every word'

Shelagh Fogarty's best moments of 2021

Shelagh Fogarty's best moments of 2021

Best of 2021: Clash with caller branding bikini-wearing girls 'shocking'

Best of 2021: Clash with caller branding bikini-wearing girls 'shocking'

Sadiq Khan: Omicron will 'surge' without new restrictions post-Christmas

Sadiq Khan: Omicron will 'surge' without new restrictions post-Christmas