Tory MP Gets A Grilling Over NHS “Brexit Dividend” Claim

18 June 2018, 13:59 | Updated: 18 June 2018, 16:06

A Conservative MP got a Shelagh Fogarty grilling when he doubled-down on Theresa May’s NHS Brexit dividend claim.

Over the weekend the Prime Minister announced an extra £20bn a year by 2023 for the health service.

She said it would be partly funded by a “Brexit dividend”, with any additional tax increases being introduced in a "fair and balanced" way.

But, the claim of a dividend from leaving the EU has been described as “tosh” by critics.

Tory MP Sarah Wollaston said it "treats the public as fools”.

Chris Philp came under attack from Shelagh Fogarty on Monday
Chris Philp came under attack from Shelagh Fogarty on Monday. Picture: PA/LBC

And when Shelagh accused Mrs May of lying, Chris Philp, MP for Croydon South, insisted there was a dividend.

He told LBC: “We currently pay [the EU] about £18bn a year gross.

“We get £4bn of that back in a rebate, that gets us down to £14bn and as you said there’s about another £4bn a year that the EU spends on scientific research and farming that we’re going to continue paying.

“The net saving from leaving the EU is around the £9-10bn a year in terms of payments we make.”

Mr Philp said once the divorce bill had been taken into consideration, 30-40 per cent of the NHS cash boost would be funded by the Brexit dividend.

The Vote Leave bus was one of the most talked about parts of the referendum campaign
The Vote Leave bus was one of the most talked about parts of the referendum campaign. Picture: PA

But, his figures then came under scrutiny from Shelagh as she alluded back to the infamous red bus during the referendum.

She interjected: “The reason we invited you on the programme was I noted you tweeting in support.

“If someone can prove to me there is a Brexit dividend I’m all ears.

“But, £150m is a damn sight less than £350m and all you could say on your Twitter feed and all you’re saying now is you ‘think’ you ‘reckon’ it will be.

“Theresa May has said no such thing!”

More Shelagh Fogarty News

See more More Shelagh Fogarty News

UK has 'five more years of stagnant living standards at best' - IFS Director

UK has 'five more years of stagnant living standards at best' - IFS Director

Ex-prisoner: Raab 'absolutely right' on using prisoners to plug labour shortages

Ex-offender: Raab 'absolutely right' on using prisoners to plug labour shortages

Government 'all over the shop' on mask-wearing, says Shadow Health Secretary

Government 'all over the shop' on mask-wearing, says Shadow Health Secretary

'It's horrific déjà vu': Ex-nurse 'terrified' at lack of Covid restrictions as cases rise

Ex-NHS staff nurse 'terrified' and 'sad' as Covid cases rise

UK faces 8,000 Covid deaths before Christmas if govt don't act, epidemiologist warns

UK faces 8,000 Covid deaths before Christmas if govt don't act, epidemiologist warns

'It's unthinkable': Iain Dale reacts to Sir David Amess' murder

'It's unthinkable': Iain Dale reacts to Sir David Amess' death

Poorer areas could see 'even larger' council tax increases than projections, says IFS Director

Poorer areas could see 'even larger' council tax increases than projected, says IFS Director

Shelagh Fogarty condemns Javid's 'insulting' and 'leaden' social care comment

Shelagh Fogarty condemns Sajid Javid's 'insulting' and 'leaden' social care comment

'There has been a failing here': Met has 'very serious questions to answer', Safeguarding minister says

Met has 'very serious questions to answer' over Everard case, says minister

Exclusive
Caller defends eco-mob blocking woman visiting mother in hospital

Caller defends eco-mob blocking woman visiting mother in hospital

'We're looking at an institutional problem and talking about it like it's one bad apple'

'Utterly rotten' Met must be 'investigated' after Couzens' sentence, activist tells LBC

'When do we say this is enough?': Women's activist questions Cressida Dick's competence

'When do we say this is enough?': Women's activist questions Cressida Dick's competence

Hariett Harman tells LBC why she wants Cressida Dick to resign

Harriet Harman tells LBC why she wants Cressida Dick to resign

'We don't tolerate the Yorkshire ripper, but we tolerate lesser offences': Shelagh Fogarty condemns tolerance of male violence

'We tolerate lesser offending by men before they go on to murder girls and women'

'Hammer out a plan': Ashworth's message for Javid as key workers struggle for fuel

'Hammer out a plan': Ashworth's message for Javid as key workers struggle for fuel

UK 'subservient to US thinking' on Afghanistan withdrawal, says Defence Select Committee Chair

UK 'subservient to US thinking' on Afghanistan withdrawal, says Tobias Ellwood